Miss. Judge Denies Divorce For Same Sex Couple - FOX 29 News Philadelphia | WTXF-TV

Miss. Judge Denies Divorce For Same Sex Couple

Posted: Updated:

DeSoto County Judge Mitchell Lundy has denied same-sex divorce on grounds that the state would have to recognize the marriage. The ruling will be appealed to the The Supreme Court.

Mississippi's first same-sex divorce case was presented before a DeSoto County Chancery Court judge in Hernando, Mississippi on October 1st.

The first-ever same-sex divorce complaint to be filed in the Magnolia State involves a lesbian couple that were legally married in San Francisco, California.

Lauren Czekala-Chatham and Dana Melancon were married in San Francisco in 2008. Two years later the two separated. Czekala-Chatham now lives in Mississippi and recently filed for divorce in DeSoto County.

"I want to get divorced in Mississippi and I am going to pursue the divorce in Mississippi," she said.

The case is complicated. Czekala-Chatham's attorney Wesley Hisaw explained that the constitutionality of the case would be argued.

Attorney Chad Reeves, who represents Melancon, said that he will push for the case to be dismissed on the grounds that Mississippi doesn't recognize same sex marriages if Czekala-Chatham doesn't agree to Melancan's terms.

"If we can get it resolved my client is open to having DesSto County Chancery Court grant the divorce," Reeves said. "But that is only if we can resolve all the issues. Outside of that, she wishes to go to California."

Reeves argues that it would be cheaper and quicker for both women to go to California to get divorced.

"Instead of wasting the time and money and the resources fighting whether or not we could be divorced, we go to California and obtain the divorce in a more expedited manner,' Reeves said.

Hisaw says that only the divorce could be taken care of in California but not the property issues. Czekala-Chatham agrees.

"I mean I want it all done here," Czekala-Chatham said. "I live here, I pay taxes here. I don't want to be treated like a second class citizen. I should be able to have the same rights to walk in and get a divorce."

If the divorce is not granted by the county chancery court and the attorney general finds it unconstitutional to do so, the case would likely be appealed.

"I mean we could always appeal it to the next level," Czekala-Chatham said. And it looks like from today's ruling that it will be appealed.

A similar case has just commenced in Kentucky, where two women married in Massachusetts are seeking a divorce.

At least one same-sex couple has been able to get a divorce in a state that doesn't officially recognize same-sex unions. In 2011, the Wyoming Supreme Court ruled that two women married in Canada could get a divorce in the state, reversing a ruling by a district judge.

The Associated Press Contributed To This Report

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • 75-Year Old Woman Hurt During Purse Snatching At South Jersey Shopping Center

    75-Year Old Woman Hurt During Purse Snatching At South Jersey Shopping Center

    Friday, August 22 2014 11:02 PM EDT2014-08-23 03:02:06 GMT
    "I'm shocked because I come here all the time and I've never had an issue ever and never felt unsafe," said Christina Polizzi of Cherry Hill. She is one of many shoppers atThe Promenade shopping Center on Route 73 in Eveshamhorrified to hear that a 75 year old woman was critically hurt from a man who snatched her purse. "That's horrible, that's horrible," said Polizzi.It happened Wednesday night around 8:30. Police say the woman was walkingwhen a man came up alongside her and violently grabbe...
    "I'm shocked because I come here all the time and I've never had an issue ever and never felt unsafe," said Christina Polizzi of Cherry Hill. She is one of many shoppers atThe Promenade shopping Center on Route 73 in Eveshamhorrified to hear that a 75 year old woman was critically hurt from a man who snatched her purse. "That's horrible, that's horrible," said Polizzi.It happened Wednesday night around 8:30. Police say the woman was walkingwhen a man came up alongside her and violently grabbe...
  • Local Military Family Behind 'Goodbye Monsters' Book, Protector

    Local Military Family Behind 'Goodbye Monsters' Book, Protector

    Friday, August 22 2014 10:00 PM EDT2014-08-23 02:00:16 GMT

    A South Jersey veteran and his wife responded to bedtime fears with a new book called "Goodbye Monsters," and it comes with a protector!

    A South Jersey veteran and his wife responded to bedtime fears with a new book called "Goodbye Monsters," and it comes with a protector!

  • Clerk Shot During Wilmington Liquor Store Robbery

    Clerk Shot During Wilmington Liquor Store Robbery

    Friday, August 22 2014 6:38 PM EDT2014-08-22 22:38:37 GMT
    A surveillance camera catches it all as two workers at Cutrona Liquors in Wilmington struggling to keep a gunman out of their North Market Street shop.
    A surveillance camera catches it all as two workers at Cutrona Liquors in Wilmington struggling to keep a gunman out of their North Market Street shop.
Powered by WorldNow

WTXF-TV
330 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106-2796

Phone: (215) 925-2929
Fax: (215) 982-5494

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices