BYRON SMITH TRIAL: Recap of closing arguments - FOX 29 News Philadelphia | WTXF-TV

BYRON SMITH TRIAL: Recap of closing arguments

Posted: Updated:
LITTLE FALLS, Minn. (KMSP) -

Byron Smith has been found guilty of first-degree murder in the Thanksgiving 2012 shooting deaths of Nick Brady and Haile Kifer in Little Falls, Minn. The jury returned a unanimous verdict after just 3 hours of deliberations.

Read more: Byron Smith guilty of first-degree murder

TERRIFIED HOMEOWNER OR BURGLAR HUNTER?

Meshbesher used his closing arguments to paint Smith as a terrified homeowner who acted with courage in the face of another break-in. He argued that, in Minnesota, homeowners have the right to kill in their own home if they fear for their life and safety.

“Nick Brady and Haile Kifer didn’t care,” Meshbesher said. “They simply don’t care.”

Brady and Kifer were shot and killed by Smith in the basement of his Little Falls home on Thanksgiving Day 2012. In his closing arguments, Meshbesher blamed the pair of unarmed teens for the choices they made.

“I’m not here to convince you what he did was right,” he told the jury. “It wasn’t nice. But it is legal. It’s not murder.”

“Had they not come in that car, on that day, to do what they were doing on private property, smash a window, crawl inside, we wouldn’t be here today,” Meshbesher said. “It was their actions that caused this whole thing.”

Prosecutor Pete Orput had a much different version of the shootings.

“I hope they feel for these victims,” Orput said. “I hope they do, despite the fact they were about to commit a burglary.”

Orput used audio recordings of the killings and Smith’s police interrogations to drive home the point that this was a premeditated, cold-blooded ambush.

“Most of us understand teenage kids do stupid things,” Orput said. “This was stupid. It cost them their lives. You believe it’s murder? It was in my view. I hope it is in the jury’s view.”

Orput likened Smith’s actions that day to deer hunting. He baited Brady and Kifer by moving his truck off his property, and then lying-in-wait in the basement with water, snack bars and a couple of guns while sitting in his favorite reading chair.

Orput called it his deer stand.

THE BYRON SMITH TRIAL

April 28: Defense rests, Byron Smith doesn't testify

April 25: Deputy told Byron Smith to call police 'right away'

April 24: Prosecution rests following autopsy details

April 24: Neighbor says 'I stand by Byron'

April 22: Chilling audio of Little Falls shootings played in court

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • When hope was gone, parents turned to Google to save baby

    When hope was gone, parents turned to Google to save baby

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 9:15 PM EDT2014-08-28 01:15:47 GMT

    They were told by multiple doctors that there was no way to save their baby. That's when they took matters into their own hands, and it ended up being the right choice.

    They were told by multiple doctors that there was no way to save their baby. That's when they took matters into their own hands, and it ended up being the right choice.

  • 28 new foods at Minnesota State Fair in 2014

    28 new foods at Minnesota State Fair in 2014

    Wednesday, June 25 2014 2:57 PM EDT2014-06-25 18:57:53 GMT
    The Minnesota State Fair is adding 28 new foods to the already massive, artery-clogging list of 500 foods from 300 different vendors. New food include everything from a bacon-wrapped turkey leg and beer gelato to a shrimp dog and chocolate salami.
    The Minnesota State Fair is adding 28 new foods to the already massive, artery-clogging list of 500 foods from 300 different vendors. New food include everything from a bacon-wrapped turkey leg and beer gelato to a shrimp dog and chocolate salami.
  • 'My cousin isn't a terrorist'

    'My cousin isn't a terrorist'

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 12:32 PM EDT2014-08-27 16:32:31 GMT
    State Department officials say a man once known as Douglas McCain, who attended Twin Cities area high schools 15 years ago, died in Syria while fighting for the terror group ISIS over the weekend -- but his cousin tells Fox 9 News she spoke to him just last Friday via Facebook and doesn't believe it.
    State Department officials say a man once known as Douglas McCain, who attended Twin Cities area high schools 15 years ago, died in Syria while fighting for the terror group ISIS over the weekend -- but his cousin tells Fox 9 News she spoke to him just last Friday via Facebook and doesn't believe it.
Widgets Magazine
Powered by WorldNow

WTXF-TV
330 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106-2796

Phone: (215) 925-2929
Fax: (215) 982-5494

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices